Posted by MichaelC-15022
When Penguin 4.0 launched in September 2016, the story from Gary Illyes of Google was that Penguin now just devalued spammy links, rather than penalizing a site by adjusting the site's ranking downward, AKA a penalty.
Apparently for Penguin there is now "less need" for a disavow, according to a Facebook discussion between Gary Illyes and Barry Schwartz of Search Engine Land back in September. He suggested that webmasters can help Google find spammy sites by disavowing links they know are bad. He also mentioned that manual actions still happen — and so I think we can safely infer that the disavow file is still useful in manual penalty recovery.
But algorithmic penalties DO still exist. A client of mine, who'd in the past built a lot of really spammy links to one of their sites, had me take a look at their backlinks about 10 days ago and build a disavow file. There was no manual penalty indicated in Search Console, but they didn't rank at all for terms they were targeting — and they had a plenty strong backlink profile even after ignoring the spammy links.
I submitted the disavow file on March 2nd, 2017. Here's the picture of what happened to their traffic:
4 days after the disavow file submission, their traffic went from just a couple hundred visits/day from Google search to nearly 3,000.
Penguin might no longer be handing out penalties, but clearly there are still algorithmic penalties handed out by Google. And clearly, the disavow file still works on these algorithmic penalties.
Perhaps we just need to give them another animal name. (Personally, I like the Okapi... goes along with the black-and-white animal theme, and, like Google algorithmic penalties, hardly anyone knows they still exist.)
I look forward to animated comments from other SEOs and webmasters who might have been suspecting the same thing!
Sign up for The Moz Top 10, a semimonthly mailer updating you on the top ten hottest pieces of SEO news, tips, and rad links uncovered by the Moz team. Think of it as your exclusive digest of stuff you don't have time to hunt down but want to read!